Utilitarianism — Greatest Good
"The greatest good for the greatest number"
제레미 벤담 (Jeremy Bentham, 1748~1832) · 존 스튜어트 밀 (John Stuart Mill, 1806~1873) · 18세기 후반
📜 Origin
In the heart of Britain's Industrial Revolution, Bentham wanted law and morality to be calculable. He proposed the "felicific calculus" — measuring happiness by intensity, duration, certainty, propinquity. His successor John Stuart Mill went further: not just quantity but quality. "Better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a pig satisfied."
💡 Meaning
Utilitarianism's core: a policy is right if its consequences are. However pure the intent, if outcomes increase suffering, the policy is wrong. This thought drove abolition (1833), women's suffrage, Poor Law reform — the basis of modern reform. The fastest translation of philosophy into policy.
🌏 Eastern Classic Cross-link
Mencius: "Rejoice with the people." 2,300 years ago Mencius made public happiness the standard of politics. If the ruler's joy is not the people's joy, it is not rule. East and West climbed toward the same standard by different paths — Mencius through virtue, Bentham through calculation.
"益" depicts a vessel (皿) overflowing — "what overflows is added." 益 is not mere "profit" but the insight that what is shared multiplies. Utilitarianism teaches the same — one person's happiness is small when sealed, large when flowing to all.
🌐 Modern Application
비용-편익 분석, 공공보건 정책, GDP 측정의 진화(행복지수), 효과적 이타주의(EA), 트롤리 문제 토론.
⚠️ Caveat
"다수의 행복"이 소수의 권리를 짓밟을 위험 — 칸트가 비판한 지점. 공리는 균형 중 한 척도여야지 유일한 척도여서는 안 됨.
🔗 Related Thoughts
To explore the hanja deeper
📜 Cheonjamun 1000 Hanja →